Most loyalty advice is written for coffee shops, where a regular comes in every morning and a stamp card fills in a fortnight. A restaurant is different. Guests come less often, spend more each time, arrive in groups, and often book ahead. A scheme that works for a café can feel stingy or confusing in a restaurant.
This guide is for owners of independent restaurants, bistros, pizzerias and family dining rooms in the UK. It covers which kind of loyalty programme suits a restaurant, rewards that do not eat your margin, how bookings fit in, the UK consent rules, and a worked example in pounds.
How restaurant loyalty differs from café loyalty
Four things change when you move from a café counter to a dining room:
- Visits are less frequent. A good regular might come once a fortnight or once a month, not three times a week.
- Spend is higher and varies a lot. A quick lunch for one and a Saturday dinner for six are very different bills.
- Guests come in groups. One person usually books and pays, but several people eat.
- Many visits start with a booking. That gives you a name and a phone number before the guest even arrives.
Each of these shapes the programme you choose.
Points, stamps or both?
Points per pound
Points suit most restaurants, because they reward spend rather than visits. A table of six earns more than a lunch for one, which feels fair to guests. You set how many points each pound earns and a short list of rewards, such as a free dessert or money off the bill.
A stamp card with a minimum spend
A stamp card can still work, especially for lunch spots, pizzerias and takeaways where spend is fairly even. Add a minimum spend for each stamp so a single side order does not count the same as a full meal. Keep the card short: 6 stamps is plenty if guests visit monthly.
Both
Some restaurants run a stamp card for weekday lunches and points for everything else. It is more to explain, so only do it if your lunch trade and evening trade really are different crowds.
For more on choosing, see our complete guide to setting up a loyalty scheme. The principles are the same, with different numbers.
Rewards that protect your margin
The best restaurant rewards have a high value to the guest and a low cost to you. Good examples:
- A free dessert. Desserts often have a lower food cost than their menu price suggests, and a guest who stays for dessert often orders a coffee too.
- A free starter or sharing plate on the next visit.
- A free soft drink or coffee for the whole table.
- A percentage off the bill, for bigger rewards, so the reward grows with the size of the table.
Be careful with alcohol as a reward. Licensing rules restrict irresponsible drinks promotions, and your premises licence may have its own conditions, so check before you offer free drinks with alcohol in them. Food and soft-drink rewards avoid the question.
Avoid rewards that cost you a whole cover, such as a free main course, unless the threshold is high to match.
A worked example: points in a neighbourhood bistro
Here is an illustration with figures you can change for your own. They are not industry averages.
- Average spend: £28 per head, including VAT; a typical table of two spends £56.
- Points: 1 point per £1.
- Reward: a free dessert, on the menu at £7, at 100 points. The dessert costs the kitchen about £1.80 to make.
- Regulars: 80 members who each visit once a fortnight as a couple.
A couple reaches 100 points in about two visits. Over a year, each couple makes 26 visits, spends £1,456 and earns about 14 free desserts. The desserts cost about £25 a year per couple, under 2% of what they spent.
Now suppose the programme brings each of those 80 couples in one extra time every two months. That is 6 extra visits a year each, or 480 visits, at £56 each: £26,880 in extra takings. Those visits earn about 270 more free desserts, worth about £1,880 at menu price but costing the kitchen about £480.
The numbers will differ for you, but the shape is the same: a reward that costs little to make, linked to a few extra visits a year, pays for itself many times over.
Bookings and loyalty
A booking is a loyalty opportunity. The guest has already given you their name and phone number, and they are coming in anyway. Three simple habits:
- Send a reminder before the booking. A message 24 hours before cuts no-shows and reminds guests you exist.
- Link the booking to the member so the visit counts.
- Use the booking note. If a regular always asks for the window table, write it down.
Bookings and loyalty work best in the same system, so the member's history, notes and points are in one place. See how table bookings work in Café QR.
Groups: who earns?
In most schemes, the person whose phone number is linked to the order earns for the whole bill. That is simple and usually what guests expect: the person who booked and paid gets the points.
If a group splits the bill, each person who pays and is a member can earn on their own share, depending on how your system handles split payments. Explain your rule clearly on the menu or sign-up page so nobody feels short-changed.
Getting guests to join
Restaurant guests are relaxed and not in a queue, so the moment to invite them is easier to find than in a busy café:
- On the menu or table card, with a QR code to join.
- When the bill arrives. "Are you in our dining club? Tonight's meal would earn you 56 points."
- In the booking confirmation, with a link to join.
Never make joining a condition of booking or ordering.
The UK consent rules for restaurant loyalty
Restaurants collect a lot of contact details through bookings, and it is tempting to treat that as a marketing list. It is not. This is a summary, not legal advice.
- Booking messages are service messages. A reminder about a booking someone made is not marketing.
- Offers need opt-in. You need clear consent before sending marketing by email, text or similar messages. A booking or a payment is not consent on its own.
- An easy way out. Every marketing message needs a simple way to stop, and you must honour it.
- No marketing without consent. Members who decline offers still earn and use their points.
- Keep records of who agreed, to which channel and when.
Common mistakes with restaurant loyalty
A few mistakes come up again and again:
- Copying a café stamp card. A 10-stamp card for a restaurant visited once a month takes most of a year to fill. Few guests will finish it.
- Rewards that cost a cover. A free main course on every full card can wipe out the margin on a whole table.
- Treating the booking list as a mailing list. Guests who booked a table did not agree to marketing. Ask separately.
- Forgetting the staff. If servers do not mention the programme when the bill arrives, most guests will never hear about it.
- No end date for old rewards. Decide how long points last, say so clearly, and remind members before they expire.
Using what you learn about members
The second benefit of a restaurant loyalty programme, after the extra visits, is knowledge. Within a few months you will see:
- Who your regulars really are. Often a smaller, more valuable group than you expected.
- When they come. If your regulars are mostly Friday diners, a Tuesday offer for members may fill a quiet night.
- Who has stopped coming. A regular couple who used to visit monthly and have not been in for three months is worth a personal note.
- What they like. Notes on a member, such as a favourite table or an allergy, help the whole team look after them.
Use this sparingly and kindly. A well-timed "we have a new autumn menu, would you like to book?" to members who agreed to hear from you is welcome. A weekly newsletter usually is not.
How it works in Café QR
Café QR includes loyalty from Order & Pay Plus (£24.99 a month) up, alongside the till, QR table ordering and online ordering.
- Set up in four steps. On the Customers page, a four-step wizard asks how your programme works, how many stamps or points, what members get and how they join, with a live preview of the guest's card.
- Stamps and points add themselves. When an order linked to the member's phone number is paid, at the till, from the table or online, the stamp or points go on by themselves. Staff never stamp anything.
- Full cards work everywhere. Members use a full stamp card at the till, on your QR menu or online, and spend points on up to four rewards at the till.
- A stamp card, points, or both. There are no tiers.
Table bookings send each guest a WhatsApp reminder 24 hours before their table, and come in the POS plan or as a £4 a month add-on. See how customer loyalty works in Café QR.
Measuring your programme
After two or three months, check:
- Members as a share of covers. How many of your guests are members?
- Return rate. How many members came back within six weeks?
- Reward use. Are rewards being used? If not, the threshold may be too high.
- Average spend of members compared with everyone else.
Change one thing at a time and give it a month before judging.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best loyalty programme for a restaurant?
For most restaurants, points per pound, because spend varies a lot between visits and points reward bigger tables fairly. Lunch spots with even spend can use a short stamp card with a minimum spend.
What rewards work well for restaurant loyalty?
Rewards with a high value to the guest and a low cost to you, such as a free dessert, a free starter or a free soft drink for the table. A percentage off the bill works for bigger rewards.
Can I use booking details for marketing?
Not on their own. Booking reminders are service messages, but marketing offers need clear consent, and every message needs an easy way to opt out.
Who earns points when a group eats together?
Usually the member whose phone number is linked to the order earns for the bill they pay. Explain your rule clearly so guests know what to expect.
Should restaurants offer free alcohol as a loyalty reward?
Be careful. Licensing rules restrict irresponsible drinks promotions and your licence may have conditions. Food and soft-drink rewards avoid the issue.